The author of the story is a motley ribbon 4 letters - crossword clue Arthur Conan Doyle “Colorful Ribbon”

A story surprising in its atmosphere, indeed, after the first reading (especially in childhood) it's scary to fall asleep. Would put highest mark, but still, for a person with a university education, Conan Doyle sometimes allowed himself too much liberties. Well, a snake cannot crawl along a cord! In my childhood I did not think about it, but in my grade, I probably got to a meeting with Vitaly in 8th Solomin. The famous "Dr. Watson" humorously told about this and other mistakes of Conan Doyle. After that, the "Motley Ribbon" was no longer so scary for me. Although respect for the talent of the writer has not gone anywhere.

Score: 9

Helen Stoner turns to Sherlock Holmes for help. Two years ago, her twin sister Julia died, and this happened two weeks before her wedding and under mysterious circumstances. Before her death, Julia heard a strange whistle, and while dying, she shouted: “My God, Helen! Ribbon! Motley ribbon! " Now Helen is preparing to get married and is very afraid, because the last few nights she hears a strange whistle ...

The Motley Ribbon attracts attention with its riddle. It seems as if this is the first time a great detective has encountered mysticism that cannot be explained by human logic. But, of course, Sherlock Holmes will figure it out and explain everything. There is tension in this story, an interesting investigation and, as in any good detective story, the reader is given the opportunity to guess everything for himself, if, of course, they so wish and put some mental effort.

One of the episodes in the life of the famous detective. It was interesting to read, but I cannot say that this story impressed me greatly. However, this is a worthy piece of adventure detective.

Score: 8

My assessment was formed from two impressions - a child's and an adult's. As a child, the story made an absolutely amazing impression. It is dark and mysterious, seeming mysticism (the villain is known, but how does he kill?). In him family drama, hopelessness and despair. In it, justice ultimately triumphs. For all the love for Doyle, there aren't many Sherlock stories that put it all together. But at the same time, impressions fade over the years. Not because you are too familiar with the twists and turns and watched the film several times. It's just that the story already resembles a children's horror story. Only in childhood can one be afraid of strange sounds at night and gypsies and believe that snakes are crawling along the walls. Therefore, it is no longer possible to give the highest mark.

Score: 8

When Arthur Conan Doyle was faced with the task of selecting 12 best stories"The Sherlokians", then the first number he put was "Motley Ribbon", writing the following: "There is a dark story about a snake," Motley Ribbon ", which, I am sure, will be on every list." It is clear that with such argumentation, deciding to post his review on Fantlab, the great writer would quickly receive it, review, deletion. Therefore, I will try to be less laconic. What's so good about "Colorful Ribbon"? Firstly, by the gloomy atmosphere of the London suburb and the horror forced upon the reader, starting with the very description of Helen Stoner, a young but early gray woman who trembled not from the London cold, but from fear. Secondly, the scheme of the crime itself is so unusual that it is almost impossible to guess before Holmes about the true events in Stoke Moron, especially since you get acquainted with the story or its adaptation at the age of 10-11. Who the murderer is is clear, but the method of the crime is hidden in darkness and we learn the whole background of what is happening simultaneously with Watson.

Neither Conan Doyle's gaps in serpentology, nor surprise at the capabilities of the Indian correspondent Grimsby Roylott, who sent him an African cheetah (in the text, cheetah) and a baboon, nor even the complexity of translators with the ambiguous word "Band" can no longer interfere with the perception of the story. somehow explain the "gypsy" version).

Score: 10

According to Conan Doyle's own (list of the Best), from 1927 - this is NUMBER ONE!

Without risking giving final assessments, nevertheless, I consider this story to be the brightest, insane and truly classic (Except The Dog of the Baskervilles); the true focus of the mystical detective - which has everything; and grotesque villain; and mysterious dying words and a vile hyena (coupled with a baboon).

And who among you, having read this story, is not amazed at the ingenious simplicity of Holmes' investigation? "Vent" leading to the next room; the cord from the "bell", calling no one - it's a classic! Everything, it would seem, is clear - but Watson understands nothing; and the reader, about and by and large, too - although the author gave all the ends.

The story is very "early"; dated April 1883; there were no more than a few stories before him. Holmes even has to explain to Helen who this mustachioed gentleman is - while later it was already clear and obvious.

If I was asked - how to characterize Holmes - I would cite this story as an example. Only 10.

Score: 10

“Oh, how much evil there is in the world, and worst of all, when he does evil deeds clever man! .. "" This man is very cunning, but I hope, Watson, that we will be able to outsmart him. " An excellent story worthy of your attention, possessing such peculiar features as those extraordinary events that are set forth in it. A vivid mysterious story, mysterious circumstances, a fascinating way of investigation and an amazing ending - ten seconds and it's all over! .. There is practically no riddle that is inaccessible to the discerning mind of private detective Sherlock Holmes.

Enjoy reading!

PS: Was Conan Doyle himself aware of the deafness of snakes at the time of writing his story, remains a mystery?

Score: 10

I love the author and the characters very much, especially this particular story. Sherlock in this story showed himself positively. He turned out to be not only a talented detective, but also a gentleman. When I read it for the first time (although it was a long time ago and my impressions were blurred), the denouement seemed just brilliant. After already, probably, the tenth reading, I am still impressed by the whole story.

I agree: in childhood, we are often afraid of the dark. But at the same time, in adulthood, this fear is not completely eliminated, it just changes. Therefore, the impressions are somewhat different from reading. You pay attention to the details, the external atmosphere of the story is no longer so frightening ...

Score: 10

Britain rules the seas, and her children, returning home from the colonies, inhabit the English outback with exotic Indian animals. London is the capital of the world empire, and right there, seemingly nearby, gypsies roam the countryside in a noisy crowd. The old mansion, as if steeped in the sins of its owners, an ancient Saxon family, becomes the site of a chilling crime.

Who will go into the historical works to check if Victorian England was like that? Still, oh Everyday life past generations, we gain insight mainly through fiction... Good literature, as in this case. The trouble is that if we leave the atmosphere outside the brackets, and take into account that the identity of the killer, in general, is not hidden, the method and the weapon become the main mystery. Holmes' observation and logical constructions, of course, are excellent, but the bloopers with a cord and a whistle do not allow to give a high assessment to the story as a detective.

P. S. I wonder if someone will be able to adequately reflect the play on words in the translation (band is both a band and a tape).

Score: 7

Miss Helen Stoner, whose sister Julia died under mysterious circumstances, remained to live in the house together with her hot-tempered stepfather, Dr. Roylett. One night she hears the same whistle that preceded her sister's death. She has no choice but to turn to the best specialist in private investigation - Mr. Sherlock Holmes.

One of the most beloved and frightening stories by the author, it is no coincidence that theatrical performance enjoyed great success. It's remarkable how Doyle tackles the problem of the charismatic villain. Here, as happens quite often in his stories, the author entrusts his criminals to the "supreme judge", obviously not wanting to try on Holmes as the arbiter of human destinies.

P.S. In my opinion, this is one of the most memorable stories. And at the same time, the one that my parents remembered first of all, telling me about the adventures of the famous detective.

Score: 9

Unfortunately, I cannot fully enjoy the story, and the Soviet film adaptation of Holmes with Livanov in the title role is "to blame" for this. For some reason, it was the part associated with this story that stuck in my mind the most, thereby noticeably breaking off the buzz that I probably would have received. But even so, knowing how it will end, I cannot help but note that the story, along with The Man with the Split Lip, is what I originally expected, what I hoped for - a clear, intense narration full of mystical secrets and, it would seem , unexplained tragedies. The thing is atmospheric and original, the “case” is not similar to the previous ones (which in the collection “The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes” turned out to be not such a frequent case), very intriguing and sometimes even frightening. And this is the case when the crime is uncommon (moreover, this is so far the first representative of such a super-complex subgenre as “murder in a closed room” I have seen in a cycle about Holmes), and its execution was made with fiction, that is, everything did not come down to something- something banal, it was on one intriguing level. And the demonstration of the deductive method here is impressive. And the criminal finally gets what he deserves, and how! One word - everything is just on top! At the very height that I had originally hoped for when I read the stories about Sherlock Holmes. It's a pity that the whole plot was already known to me "thanks" to the vividly remembered film adaptation. However, this did not prevent you from getting pleasure from the story. The only moment you can probably catch on is -

Spoiler (plot disclosure) (click on it to see)

no, not that snakes cannot climb rope, this has been said many times already

- I was embarrassed that, as you know, the fence in front of the house "collapsed in many places", however, both the baboon and the leopard walked inside this fence, and, apparently, did not try to escape ... It seemed very strange to me. In general, everything was just great - atmospheric, intriguing, tense and very interesting.

Score: 8

One of the strongest human instincts is the instinct of self-preservation. It is he who makes us afraid of snakes, since hundreds of generations of our ancestors for thousands of years hammered this into our subconsciousness. Conan Doyle skillfully used this fear in his story. A whistling knock, a mysterious motley ribbon and when you come to the finale - Horror cools your body when you imagine how a deadly creature slowly crawls along the blanket under which YOU sleep. Of course, this belongs to the category of childhood fears, but after reading the story at a young age, I fell asleep very hard for several nights. : super.

A trembling young woman named Ellen Stoner turns to Sherlock Holmes for help.

Ellen's father served in India as a major general of artillery. He died, leaving a decent fortune. When the girl and her twin sister Julia were two years old, her mother married Dr. Grimsby Roylott, the son of one of the wealthiest families in England. One of his relatives lost his entire fortune, and Roylott had to earn his own living. The girls' mother died in a train accident. According to her will, all the money went to her husband, but if the daughters get married, a certain part should be allocated to each. The family returned to England and settled near London in the Roylott family estate.

Roylott is a very violent and hot-tempered person with immense physical strength. He does not communicate with neighbors, but is friends with gypsies who have spread their camp on the territory of the estate. He brought animals from India, and a baboon and a cheetah roam the estate.

Two years ago, Julia was proposed by a retired major. The stepfather did not mind the marriage of his stepdaughter. Two weeks before the wedding, Julia came to Ellen's room before going to bed. Julia's bedroom was located between the bedrooms of her sister and stepfather, and the windows of all three rooms overlooked the lawn where the gypsy camp was spread. Julia complained that someone was whistling at night, she heard an iron clang, and the smell of strong cigars, which her stepfather smoked, prevented her from sleeping.

At night, the girls always locked the door with a key, as they were afraid of animals. There was a terrible scream that night. Jumping out into the corridor, Ellen saw her sister in a nightgown, white with horror. Julia staggered like a drunk, then fell, writhing in pain and convulsions. She was trying to show something, shouting at the same time: "Colorful ribbon." The arriving doctor could not save her, Julia died. After examining the circumstances of the death, the police concluded that the girl died of a nervous shock, since no one could enter her room, locked and with closed windows. No poison was found either.

Now Ellen has met the man who proposed to her. The stepfather does not object to the marriage, but he started renovations in the house, and Ellen had to move to her late sister's room. At night, the girl heard a strange whistle and an iron clang, which were a harbinger of Julia's death. She asks for help from the great detective. Sherlock Holmes promises to come to the Roylott estate in the evening and study the situation.

Soon after the visitor leaves the apartment on Baker Street, Grimsby Roylott himself visits. He has tracked down his stepdaughter and threatens the great detective.

Sherlock Holmes makes inquiries and finds out that the marriage of girls is very unprofitable for Roylott: his income will significantly decrease.

After examining the estate, Sherlock Holmes comes to the conclusion that repairs were not needed. He started in order to force Ellen to move to her sister's room. In Julia's room, he is interested in the long malfunctioning bell cord hanging over the bed, and the bed itself, bolted to the floor. The cord is tied to a small vent that does not go outside, but into the next room where Roylott lives. In Dr. Holmes's room, he finds an iron fireproof cabinet, which, according to Ellen, contains business papers, a whip tied in a noose, and a small saucer of milk.

The great detective intends to spend the night in Ellen's room, having removed the girl to a safe place. He is going to prevent a subtle and terrible crime that a doctor, a man with nerves of steel, is committing.

In the middle of the night, a gentle whistle is heard, and Holmes begins to violently beat the cord with his cane. A terrible cry is immediately heard. Holmes and Watson rush to Roylott's room. The door of the fireproof closet is open, Roylott is sitting on a chair in a dressing gown, a whip is in his lap, and a colorful ribbon wraps around his head. The doctor is dead. Suddenly the ribbon moves and the head of a poisonous snake, a swamp Indian viper, is shown. Holmes throws a whip on her and locks her in the closet.

Upon discovering the fake bell and the screwed-on bed, the great detective realized that the cord served as a bridge connecting the fan to the bed. And at the sight of a whip and a saucer of milk, Holmes got the idea of ​​a snake. After living for many years in India, Roylott found an undetectable poison, and an investigator must have very keen eyesight to see the tiny teeth marks of a viper.

Having teased the snake with a cane, Holmes forced it to attack the owner. The great detective is indirectly responsible for the death of Grimsby Roylott, but this death cannot be said to have been a heavy burden on his conscience.

You have read the summary of the story The Motley Ribbon. In you can read summaries and other books.

The stepfather kills one of his stepdaughters by launching a deadly poisonous snake into the girl's bedroom. Sherlock Holmes rescues his second stepdaughter and punishes the murderer.

A trembling young woman named Ellen Stoner turns to Sherlock Holmes for help.

Ellen's father served in India as a major general of artillery. He died, leaving a decent fortune. When the girl and her twin sister Julia were two years old, her mother married Dr. Grimsby Roylott, the son of one of the wealthiest families in England. One of his relatives lost his entire fortune, and Roylott had to earn his own living. The girls' mother died in a train accident. According to her will, all the money went to her husband, but if the daughters get married, a certain part should be allocated to each. The family returned to England and settled near London in the Roylott family estate.

Roylott is a very violent and hot-tempered person with immense physical strength. He does not communicate with neighbors, but is friends with gypsies who have spread their camp on the territory of the estate. He brought animals from India, and a baboon and a cheetah roam the estate.

Two years ago, Julia was proposed by a retired major. The stepfather did not mind the marriage of his stepdaughter. Two weeks before the wedding, Julia came to Ellen's room before going to bed. Julia's bedroom was located between the bedrooms of her sister and stepfather, and the windows of all three rooms overlooked the lawn where the gypsy camp was spread. Julia complained that someone was whistling at night, she heard an iron clang, and the smell of strong cigars, which her stepfather smoked, prevented her from sleeping.

At night, the girls always locked the door with a key, as they were afraid of animals. There was a terrible scream that night. Jumping out into the corridor, Ellen saw her sister in a nightgown, white with horror. Julia staggered like a drunk, then fell, writhing in pain and convulsions. She was trying to show something, shouting at the same time: "Colorful ribbon." The arriving doctor could not save her, Julia died. After examining the circumstances of the death, the police concluded that the girl died of a nervous shock, since no one could enter her room, locked and with closed windows. No poison was found either.

Now Ellen has met the man who proposed to her. The stepfather does not object to the marriage, but he started renovations in the house, and Ellen had to move to her late sister's room. At night, the girl heard a strange whistle and an iron clang, which were a harbinger of Julia's death. She asks for help from the great detective. Sherlock Holmes promises to come to the Roylott estate in the evening and study the situation.

Soon after the visitor leaves the apartment on Baker Street, Grimsby Roylott himself visits. He has tracked down his stepdaughter and threatens the great detective.

Sherlock Holmes makes inquiries and finds out that the marriage of girls is very unprofitable for Roylott: his income will significantly decrease.

After examining the estate, Sherlock Holmes comes to the conclusion that repairs were not needed. He started in order to force Ellen to move to her sister's room. In Julia's room, he is interested in the long malfunctioning bell cord hanging over the bed, and the bed itself, bolted to the floor. The cord is tied to a small vent that does not go outside, but into the next room where Roylott lives. In Dr. Holmes's room, he finds an iron fireproof cabinet, which, according to Ellen, contains business papers, a whip tied in a noose, and a small saucer of milk.

The great detective intends to spend the night in Ellen's room, having removed the girl to a safe place. He is going to prevent a subtle and terrible crime that a doctor, a man with nerves of steel, is committing.

In the middle of the night, a gentle whistle is heard, and Holmes begins to violently beat the cord with his cane. A terrible cry is immediately heard. Holmes and Watson rush to Roylott's room. The door of the fireproof closet is open, Roylott is sitting on a chair in a dressing gown, a whip is in his lap, and a colorful ribbon wraps around his head. The doctor is dead. Suddenly the ribbon moves and the head of a poisonous snake, a swamp Indian viper, is shown. Holmes throws a whip on her and locks her in the closet.

Upon discovering the fake bell and the screwed-on bed, the great detective realized that the cord served as a bridge connecting the fan to the bed. And at the sight of a whip and a saucer of milk, Holmes got the idea of ​​a snake. After living for many years in India, Roylott found an undetectable poison, and an investigator must have very keen eyesight to see the tiny teeth marks of a viper.

Having teased the snake with a cane, Holmes forced it to attack the owner. The great detective is indirectly responsible for the death of Grimsby Roylott, but this death cannot be said to have been a heavy burden on his conscience.

Plot

A girl named Helen Stoner turned to Sherlock Holmes for help. She lives in the old estate of Stoke Moron with her stepfather, Dr. Grimsby Roylott, a man from a respected family. Two years ago, the girl lost her sister Julia, who died two weeks before her wedding under mysterious circumstances. Before her death, for several nights she heard a strange whistle in the house, which frightened her very much. On the night Julia died, Helen heard similar sounds. Dying, Julia shouted: "It was a colorful ribbon!" Apparently, this was not delirium, and Helen was greatly alarmed. Now her stepfather started repairs in the house, and Helen had to temporarily move to the room of her late sister. At night, she also began to hear whistles and therefore decided to turn to Sherlock Holmes for help.

Holmes first comes to erroneous conclusions, thinking that these are the affairs of the gypsies who lived on the territory of the estate. But having arrived in Stoke-Moron and having examined the house, Holmes concludes that nothing could threaten the girl outside, the danger was in the house itself. Holmes later discovers a strange vent leading to his stepfather's room, and a bell rope that does not ring and is not even a bell per se.

Comparing all the facts, Sherlock comes up with the idea of ​​a snake. She used a rope to descend into the victim's bed (the bed was screwed to the floor so that the victim could not move it), and with the help of a bowl of milk, Dr. Roylott learned to return her back. Holmes and Watson spend the night in Helen Stoner's room and encounter a snake. Holmes cane her back into the vent. In the snake, her snake malice awakens, and in a rage she bites the first one who caught her - the doctor himself. Grimsby Roylott is killed by the poison almost instantly.

Quote

Snake

• Swamp Viper Swamp adder) is a snake invented by Conan Doyle. African snakes of the genus Proatheris are called swamp vipers, and also - in Russian everyday speech - a common inhabitant of swamps, the common viper.
• In addition, in his story, Doyle made a fundamental mistake of not knowing zoology, which was "corrected" in the Soviet film adaptation of this adventure of Holmes: Dr. Watson, performed by Vitaly Solomin, explains to his friend that Roylott could not call the snake back with a whistle, since the snakes are deaf (which Sherlock didn't know about). This is why Holmes, sung by Vasily Livanov, adds a phrase about the strange "banging" on the wall, since the vibration easily attracts the attention of deaf animals. Whether Conan Doyle himself knew about the deafness of snakes at the time of writing his story remains a mystery.

It is noteworthy that in the later (1986) British film adaptation of "The Spotted Ribbon" Doyle's misconception about whistling was preserved.

Screen adaptations

• The story was filmed by director Igor Maslennikov - the first episode of the film "Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson".
• TV series "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes". Made in Great Britain 1984-1994 Season 1 "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes", Episode 6 "Colorful Ribbon"

Write a review on the article "Colorful Ribbon"

Notes (edit)

Links